We, the Barbarians: Vipul Rikhi

Guest post by VIPUL RIKHI

 We’re not a civilisation. We’re a horde. And baying for blood is the new flavour of the season.

Let us have a few more executions while we’re at it. Why stop the fun now? Let us distribute sweets and dance on the streets. Why hide these killings inside jails? Let’s bring them out into the open, so the whole populace can rejoice and the collective conscience of the people can be appeased.

If there’s not enough terrorists, there are rapists. There are enough people to round up and hang. As with the six who raped and murdered a girl on a bus in Delhi, our collective cry must be, ‘kill them all!’ There are clear villains in each piece, and we are the pure ones who are always getting outraged.

Vandalism and righteousness are the new values. Stridency is the new voice. Violence is the new activism. Swoop down on more ice-cream joints in the manner of Mangalore and heckle and humiliate young couples. Arrest more girls for Facebook posts and likes. Create an outcry at every other film, book or utterance. Imprison people who make unacceptable paintings and cartoons, especially of those in power. Arrest authors and speakers; attack and vandalise publications. Forbid women from dressing at all, as in all the coolest films, unless they submit to covering every inch of their bodies. Condemn them if they do, and condemn them if they don’t.

Confronted with an attack by the ‘enemy’, we display our strength and might as a nation. We flex our numerous muscles. Our national honour and asmita are enhanced by not allowing terrorists to meet their families before they die. We feel fulfilled and strong by dancing on the streets to celebrate a killing, and get our kicks from being covered by lustful media.

We have tasted blood. We won’t stop now. A bit of frenzy never hurt anyone. Certainly not us.


When we condemn a society, we must condemn it wholesale. It is not that ‘liberals’ are somehow better people because of their claims to espouse a ‘right set of values’. No matter what label we are, we are a horde. We have our own set of fundamentalisms. No matter who ‘we’ are, we have an ‘us’ and a ‘them’. It’s always ‘they’ who are the problem.

But look closely and you will find that something is rotten in the entire state of Denmark. It is not one section or the other. A public culture that is steeped in noise-making and rabble-rousing is constituted by all of us. Collective aspirations that are deeply laced with self-seeking and lust for personal power and success are held in force by all of us. We’re the ones we are dying to fight and kill. We are the ones we are gunning for. In a macabre sense, it might be only logical for us to do so.

There can be several ways to look at a culture’s gradual descent into madness. There are several kinds of insanity as well; for instance, the carefully sanitised and regulated insanity of the west. But ours is much more colourful (we who pride ourselves on our joie de vivre) and in the face. Our shit and piss is always out in the open.

It is a mistake to think that we know who we are. We are only just finding out. It’s coming out more and more as the times get fast and furious. We’re a fanciful ‘superpower’ in the making, ‘modern’, ‘developed’ and getting richer. Our wealth and modernity make us only more rabid and frenzied. We spew more venom, vitriol, banality and noise on our television and in our newspapers, and buy more touch-phones, flat screens and other gadgets that make us appear cool and evolved, with which we boost our collective self-image.

We’re too clever by half. We win more and more international awards and preen to ourselves. We are ‘forgiven’ by the international business community for our occasional rioting and accepted back into the fold. We are all glamour and shimmer, all power and pull, all surface culture and sophistication. The literati are a horde. The liberal intellectuals are a horde. The politicians are a horde. The businessmen and women are a horde. The right-wingers are a horde. The gurus, mullahs and pandits are a horde. The middle class is a horde. Bollywood is a horde. (The poor are a horde who don’t count.)

It is all interconnected. It all ties in. if we don’t get the links, it is because we’re not looking. We don’t want to look. Because that is not our culture. Our culture is to catch and execute. Our culture is to chase and acquire. Our culture is to be righteous and self-satisfied. Our culture is to pronounce moronic judgements on television and to accept those verdicts.

We are exactly what we deserve. A mob will lynch a mob. We just don’t want to admit what we have become. Shadows are soothing and comfortable, and the level of din more than makes up for the lack of light. But let’s face it – there will be blood. There are more attractions forthcoming in 2014, and perhaps before and certainly after. Hang on to your seats (unless ‘they’ cart you away first to the gallows).

There is no ‘them’. There is no enlightened, elevated, superior, rabidly righteous ‘us’. We’re all them. We’re all us. They’re all us.

I am. You are. We all are.

(Vipul Rikhi is a Bangalore-based writer)

15 thoughts on “We, the Barbarians: Vipul Rikhi”

  1. It appears that you do not know who will fulfill your wishes. In one ward we all are wild Monkeys yet live in diversified way. We are going back to stone age perhaps, why regret?


      1. Mr. Vasu, do you think you are the owner of Kafila site & what you talk or think are the right one. Do not live in fool’s paradise.


  2. the concept of civilization depends on self control of human being on their wants/needs/desires. As a “race”, irrespective of west or east, we desire more. Hence we are not a civilization. Since that is out of the window, we go back to jungle raaj and so whoever can survive will survive. Don’t get frustrated – you didn’t ask to be born here but here you are. And if you are feeling it strongly, as Gandhi said “Be the change you want to see in the world”.


  3. I have mostly loved what people write here but cannot say the same about what you have written … everyone has perspectives and I appreciate all of them but even with my best efforts cannot understand your viewpoint.


  4. v true.. though v depressing. and IMO we’re a horde coz we don’t have the courage to take a stand alone..we need to hide behind a mob. :(


  5. us and them, them and us… how long I have been fighting this within myself. I am not the guy jumping in the street, baying for blood and hanging and I find it difficult to identify with such a person. And yet I am he, or am I? I surely do vent my anger and and raise my voice in self-righteousness. Sometimes. These are times to look inward, to look at oneself as a third person.


  6. You have done what intellectuals in the past have done… Identifying the resemblance between old and new, animals and men, tradition and modernity, them and us. I agree with you on the collective malevolent but emotional sentiment if the crowd but I’d disagree to not notice a glimmer of light, hope in these times of great depravity, immorality, violence and all that’s negative. I think wherein a tiny ripple of change & positivity is made, one should support it, voice their optimism rather than just sit back, crouch over the one’s intellectual veneer and paint everything black.


We look forward to your comments. Comments are subject to moderation as per our comments policy. They may take some time to appear.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s