Aam Aadmi Mohalla Clinics Set to Shut Thanks to L-G and BJP Controlled Municipal Bodies: Jyoti Punwani

[The Superintendent of Tihar Jail, went a joke recently circulating on WhatsApp, had staked his claim for the Chief Ministership of Delhi, because he had the requisite number of MLAs! The mainstream (Big) media has had a field day, reporting with great ‘earnestness’, what even the ordinary person on the street can see is an orchestrated move to harass and discredit the AAP. A leading paper even did a status report on all the cases against AAP MLAs a couple of days ago, as if it was simply ‘reporting’ (with a straight face). Some day, hopefully we will be able to come out with a more detailed analysis of the ways in which sections of the big media have – even in the person/s of their most benign representatives and columnists – played footsie with the regime at the Centre. This dispensation and its utterly unprincipled and unethical ways are truly unprecedented and this phase of our history has emerged as the dirtiest chapter of parliamentary democracy in India. In the meantime, online news forums have kept the tradition of actual reportage and fairness alive. Here are some extracts from a report by JYOTI PUNWANI, courtesy The Hoot (linked below), on the mohalla clinics and the strange politics of the media that surrounds reportage around such measures undertaken by the Delhi government.]

The AAP’s mohalla clinic experiment drew the attention of The Washington Post. Its article (`What New Delhi’s free clinics can teach America’, March 11, 2016) was also carried by the Chicago Tribune. A University of Southern California delegation came to study mohalla clinics  in July.

But our print media didn’t think this important experiment was anything special. Not all covered it; of those that did, some didn’t carry the report in all their editions….

The Indian Express carried a long report in April, after the second batch of clinics opened, in its Delhi edition (“In rented rooms across Delhi, part 2 of ‘mohalla’ clinic project takes off’’).  Livemint hada detailed report last month, after more than 100 clinics had opened (`Mohalla clinic: AAP offers affordable healthcare model at doorstep’); and earlier this week, The Hindu evaluated their performance in its Delhi edition (`A thousand promises of prompt health care’).

Among news websites, Newslaundry did a lively report immediately after the first clinic opened (`Mohalla clinics come to town’). In January, Catch News did a report  (`#MohallaClinics: AAP has diagnosed Delhi’s health problem. Can it cure it?’), and a follow-up in April after the second batch opened (`AAP Mohalla clinics: rented homes turn clinics, private docs appointed’).

A two-part article appeared in Scroll.in in May (`The clinic at your doorstep: How the Delhi government is rethinking primary healthcare…) Indeed, news websites, rather than newspapers, seem to have given the new experiment the space it deserves.

Going through the reports on mohalla clinics, it became clear that the possible removal of some of them was only the latest move against them. A few days before the NDMC issued this order, the Lieutenant General (LG) of Delhi had got into the act. Consider the sequence of events:

On August 5, the Delhi High Court ruled that the LG was the administrative head of the capital. After the judgment, Deputy CM Manish Sisodia specially requested Najeeb Jung not to transfer the Health and Education secretaries as these two bureaucrats were essential for the AAP’s new initiatives in these sectors.

On August 31, Delhi papers reported the transfer of these two officials by the LG. The man put in charge of Health was the Environment Secretary. Reportedly, the AAP government had recently sought action against this gentleman for delaying the ban on the deadly Chinese manjha used for flying kites. To further twist the knife in the wound, he was not transferred out of the Environment ministry and made Health Secretary, but given additional charge of health.

This action was taken after chikungunya had started wreaking havoc in Delhi. The transfer was reported on August 31; on the same day, The Quint reported more than 400 cases of chikungunya and dengue each in the capital…

Days after the transfers came the NDMC’s order about the removal of porta-cabins. The NDMC is BJP-controlled.

Both Jung’s actions and the North Delhi Municipal Corporation’s order,  so far as it affected mohalla clinics, were arbitrary acts which endangered the health of Delhi’s poorest citizens. Enough space has been devoted to the AAP-Jung fight. But such actions form the nitty gritty of the dispute. Without knowledge of how exactly the LG is thwarting the measures being taken by a government elected by an unprecedented mandate, the AAP-Jung conflict  ends up looking like a fight between two executive heads, one of them hysterical. That’s exactly the way the media has projected it. Why?…Read the full report here.

One thought on “Aam Aadmi Mohalla Clinics Set to Shut Thanks to L-G and BJP Controlled Municipal Bodies: Jyoti Punwani”

  1. Modi has always harassed his lowest detractors since he became CM of Gujarat in 2001.Even if the person is not a politician or closest ally of his and has fell fowl of Modi for any reason,suffer he/she must; the case in point were Mallka Sarabnai, a danseuse of Gujarat and Sanjay Joshi , a RSS pracharak like him and his mantris and senior.
    So suffering of AAP is ensured as far as Modi is alive(not ruling, mind you).
    But the history has its own ways.If knows that it may help him.If not history does not spare any body.


Leave a Reply to Dinesh Shah Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s