The Death of a Historian – A Tribute to Biswamoy Pati: Saurabh Mishra

Guest post by SAURABH MISHRA

Historian Biswamoy Pati

These days, when lynch mobs, cow-killings, and aggressive patriotism dominate the headlines, what does the passing away of a mere historian mean? Not much, it seems. Yet, for those who knew Dr Biswamoy Pati, or had the good fortune of being taught by him, this has caused nothing short of a major storm in their lives.

I got to know Dr Pati in the summer of 1996, when he was a young and energetic lecturer in Delhi. I waited eagerly for his lectures (as did everyone else), which were really my first introduction into new ways of thinking about the world.

Over the years, my perception of him went through various phases – from ambivalence, to adulation/awe, to a deep emotional dependence on him, and various shades in between. This summer, as I arrived in Delhi, I was looking forward to seeing him again. Little did I know that our telephonic conversation the week before would end up being the final one.

During the time that I have known him, I have seen him struggle to make sense of the rapid gamut of changes in India and elsewhere. We made our acquaintance in a post-liberalisation Delhi, when Coca Cola and Pepsi were beginning to make their presence felt. I saw him try to grapple with Hindu nationalism, which went against everything that he had always stood for. I saw him struggle with the changing nature of left politics in India. In the last decade or so, he was trying to come to terms with an aggressive consumerism that appeared to challenge his ‘old-world values’ of honesty, frugality and simplicity. Perhaps his refusal to give up his old denim jacket, and his ridiculously outdated mobile phone, were his private rebellion against everything that was changing around him. ‘Go and meet him/her’, he would often tell me, ‘s/he is one of those old-fashioned people you will really like’.

All this came across clearly in the scholarship that he produced, which was deeply motivated by his constant political engagement with everything that was happening around him. As communalism became an ugly reality, he decided to write a history of conversions; when the mainstream media chose to ignore the existence of tribal people (except as obstacles to ‘progress’), he decided to devote his life’s work to them; and as the privatisation of health care reached unprecedented heights, he chose to work on a social history of medicine in the subcontinent. As one of his students recalled, he believed that one needed to “understand the margins, and the history of the centre [would] automatically fall into place.”[1]

Perhaps the most inspiring thing about Dr Pati was the way in which he conducted himself. For someone like me, whose previous socialisation had been in hyper-masculine and deeply hierarchical settings, his absolute refusal to put himself above his students, or his ability to interact with everyone in exactly the same egalitarian way, appeared to present a completely new way of being in the world. In an academic setting that often replicates the hierarchical conditions that it attempts to critique, he was one of those who consciously challenged it through his life and work.

There is much to say when it comes to someone with such passionate beliefs. I wish people like him, who show the courage to go against conventional ways of thinking, or to challenge powers-that-be, received more attention. It is not difficult at all to understand, though, why those who like to form easy opinions, or froth with righteous rage at imagined enemies, would not be interested in him.

—————-

[1]ShivanginiTandon, ‘Remembering BiswamoyPati, the Professor who Helped Understand History from the Margins’, 30 June 2017, The Wire. 

Saurabh Mishra is a Lecturer in History at the University of Sheffield. He was taught by Dr Biswamoy Pati at Sri Venkateswara College between 1996 and 1999.

8 thoughts on “The Death of a Historian – A Tribute to Biswamoy Pati: Saurabh Mishra

  1. K SHESHU BABU

    Fitting tributes to a historian who viewed history through the lenses of changing times and situations

  2. Dr Roopali Sircar Gaur

    He lived what he researched and wrote and spoke about. Honesty in personal, public and academic life is how I will always remember him.

  3. Shubha

    There will be many big historians before and after him. But there will be no teacher like him..the biggest loss is for his students. RIP, Sir!

  4. Shalmaly

    He used humour so well to disarm other person’s argument, even while analysing and presenting his logic. The first person I knew who broke the hierarchy that is present even in the teacher-student relation. A through professional historian with a deeply caring warm heart. This was not the right time to go Sir!

  5. Moumita Chakraborti

    Dr. Biswamoy pati was my FRIEND, PHILOSOPHER and Ph D GUIDE. He was more a father, a teacher and above all a profoundly deep-rooted democratic human being who denied any social injustice or evils. After the death of my father, he wrote, ‘ I took a day to cry Moumita’ and on recent demise of my mother he used to call me frequently to soothe my sorrow in spite of his severe illness.
    I’m not yet in a condition to write more about his contribution in my life or rather millions of student’s lives but he was an individual whose biography was worth to be written in the heart of his students.

  6. We shared the same school called Stewart in Cuttack,Odisha.Frail and small he was,born to a family who had leftist inclinations.He loved to act and was very expressive physically while making his point.These were a decade or so in the sixties.Caught up with him at Delhi University when he was graduating in history from Ramjas.These were the days of Emergency and I do not recall we being involved or very aware.We were from Odisha who had come to become career bureaucrats or as Late Frank Thakurdas used to say the oriyas gave their notes and hearts to every pretty girl they saw.Only to return home with their notes”.Then i went on my way to other callings only to hear of the remarkable strides he had made in teaching and researching on Indian History especially about Odisha and the people at the margins.He was the chosen pupil of the famous Sumit Sarkar ,the historian teacher from Kirorimal College.Pati was seen at the barricades, had become a member of the student wing of the CPI(M) and was known to be actively making time between teaching and political activism.I am sure he surprised most of us for having stuck to his dreams and never took the Civil Services exam.He never looked his part, those days.Unless, I was unable to see more than what my eyes saw.I am so happy for having been blind.At least the world saw much more in him and are richer for it.All those who came to know him and those that read today his books cherish Pati the man as well his materialist views of history.I mourn and miss him like all of them.Rest easy .Rest well.Pat, you deserved it.

  7. Ani

    Such a beautiful written piece about a beautiful human being, a great historian and an amazing teacher. Why do good people have to go early as a matter of rule?

We look forward to your comments. Comments are subject to moderation as per our comments policy. They may take some time to appear.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s