The Banality of Shame

BANAL: everyday, ordinary, commonplace

SHAME: the  painful  feeling  arising  from  the  consciousness  of  something  dishonourable done  by  oneself  or another

 

Jana gana mana adhinayaka jaya he

An auto-rickshaw and a street hawker’s pushcart as showpieces in the Commonwealth Games Village dining hall

* MCD to raze dhabas on Games route: It doesn’t matter if you are running your business legally or illegally. If your shops fall on the route of a Games event, chances are that you will have to shut shop. A shop and taxi stand in front of Bal Bhawan — which have been running for 20 years — were demolished by MCD on Saturday and the civic agency is planning to raze all dhabas  functioning along the stretch in the coming days even as the dhaba owners claim that they have been paying rent to MCD.

* Delhi street vendors evicted before Commonwealth Games: Every day for the past 30 years, Ram Prakash has been selling fruit in Delhi’s Sarojini Nagar market. He earns between 150 and 200 rupees ($3 and $4) a day, with which he supports the nine members of his family. But now the Indian capital is getting ready to host the 11-day Commonwealth Games in October and Ram Prakash has been told by the civic authorities to pack up and leave.

* Traffic Police To Launch Drive To Discipline Auto-Rickshaw Drivers: The Delhi Traffic Police is in no mood to let the errant auto-rickshaw drivers in the Capital fleece foreign visitors during the Commonwealth Games.

* Auto-drivers must carry roughly sixteen documents with them at all times, including a licence, a commercial badge, vehicle fitness certificate, pollution control certificates for the past year amongst others. To get each compulsory document, the driver must make an application to the Transport Department. However, each application requires a long list of supporting documents (as many as fifteen), which most auto-wallahs simply do not have and have little chance of obtaining: A fifty-year-old driver applying for a commercial badge may be asked for his old school certificates from rural Bihar in the 1960s whilst Delhi ID and ration cards are standard for many applications, documents which migrant drivers do not possess and have virtually no chance of getting. Aware that these requirements are impossible to meet, Transport Department officials solicit bribes from drivers to overlook gaps in applications and often even to process complete applications.

Given the sheer weight of paperwork a driver must carry around and some pedantic traffic rules, the Traffic Police are able to stop an auto-driver at random and find an excuse to challan him retrospectively. The officer simply keeps asking to see documents: he is bound to find one or two which the auto-wallah is missing. If not, then he can issue a challan for “wrong uniform” (including wearing the “wrong socks”), “incorrect lettering on auto” (Rs.1500 challan) or “illegal stopping” (despite the fact that the city’s 312 auto-stands are unmarked and no one knows where they are. Tiny Pune has over 1000 marked stands). Often the challanning officer knocks a few rupees off the challan and pockets the auto-wallah’s money. Simon Harding at kafila.org

***********************************************************

bharata bhagya vidhata…

Conditions at the Commonwealth Games Village

These rooms are clean to both you and us. However, it may not appear so to some others. They want certain standards in hygiene and cleanliness which may differ from our perception.” (Lalit Bhanot, Games Organizing Committee Secretary-General)

************************************************************

…tava shubha name jage, tava shubha ashish mange,

* Recession Hits Commonwealth Games, Budget To Be Increased In View Of The Financial Crisis: Kalmadi (Jan 06, 2009)
The global economic meltdown has hit the preparation of 2010 Commonwealth Games and Indian Olympic Association president Suresh Kalmadi on Tuesday said the budget for the mega-event will be increased in view of the financial crisis.

* Centre Mulling `Bailout’ For Realtors, Developers And Investors In The Games Village Projects: (January 13, 2009): The government is looking into a monetary mechanism to “bail out” realtors, developers and investors in the Commonwealth Games Village projects, who have been left high and dry post the global financial meltdown.

* Govt treads cautiously on contracts: (February 1, 2009) Eyebrows are being raised in high government circles over several complaints alleging that attempts are being made to influence decisions to award lucrative contracts associated with the 2010 Commonwealth Games to favourites.

**********************************************************

gahe tava jaya-gatha

Workers and families at commonwealth games sites


* Court-appointed committee that visited CWG sites: “Across sites on an average one toilet is available for 114 workers; workers in the absence of adequate number of toilets at sites are forced to defecate in the open…

“At many locations toilets are cleaned only on a weekly or monthly basis and not every day”…

At one Games Village workers’ camp, the committee noted that on average four workers were sharing a 50-square-foot room. “There were no beddings provided except for a plywood [plank]. It is a pity that it is called a bed.”

* Death sparks building worker riot in Delhi:After a fatal accident on the Commonwealth Games construction site more than thousand building workers destroyed company offices, cars and trucks.

***********************************************************

Jana-gana-mangala-dayaka jaya he,

Bharata-bhagya-vidhata



Indian Women’s Relay team at Commonwealth Youth games

* Women hockey players thank ‘whistleblower’: Sometime last week – “after repeatedly hitting a bottleneck as they tried to get their voice heard by the sports ministry” – members of the Indian women’s hockey team made up their mind not to further pursue sexual harassment charges against coach Maharaj Kishan Kaushik. They had instead decided to “reconcile themselves to the situation” and “concentrate on the game.” That is till a “good samaritan” decided to send an anonymous tell-all letter along with unseemly pictures of team videographer Basavaraja to the ministry…

Sunita Lakra, another India player, added her bit by saying, “Ranjita would often break down but we couldn’t do much about it except to tell her to keep concentrating on the game and avoid Kaushik at all cost which was a difficult thing to do since he was the coach. We knew Kaushik was powerful. We knew how he went scot free when Helen Mary had complained against him and Saini. We knew we didn’t have evidence against Kaushik except for us eye-witnesses so when someone posted the letter and the pics, we were more than happy.”

*Malleswari wants IWF secretary sacked: Sydney Olympics bronze medallist Karnam Malleswari on Sunday demanded the sacking of Indian Weightlifting Federation Secretary Sahdev Yadav for not paying heed to her repeated complaints against coach Ramesh Malhotra, who has been suspended on charges of sexually harassing junior lifters.

**********************************************************
Jaya he, jaya he, jaya he, jaya jaya jaya jaya he!


 

10 thoughts on “The Banality of Shame”

  1. The authority is trying to show some foreigners who may visit for the games as if India is like this- i.e. there are no dhabas on the roads, there are no street vendors in our markets,no beggars ,there are scenic landscaped gardens full of flowers on both sides of the roads,there are no fleecer auto/ taxis etc – in short they dont want to show that this is a poor country where …..20 rs a day etc……so many % etc…..
    Though the money for this display of 15 days comes from the direct/ indirect taxes paid by these very same people whom they are trying to banish.

    Like

  2. ayesha jalal more than a decade ago advanced this thesis: indian democracy has very visible authoritarian undercurrents. indian social scientists were dismissive because she happens to be from pakistan. she was and is right has been shown again and again. all of us have examples of visible authoritarian undercurrents(are they undercurrents?)–films cannot be made and if made cannot be shown; muslims are forced to remove name-plates from their houses; women are raped and murdered by the indian army;naxals can kill anyone who does not subscribe to their idea of revolution and justice; stalinists and neo-liberals have the same murderous methods of acquiring land; untouchability and casteism is perhaps the most rampant one etc. etc.

    Like

  3. Below I paste a report from hindustan times:
    Blame it on the Delhi Police if tomorrow your maid, car cleaner, plumber and other house help don’t show up. The police are forcing daily-wagers and migrant labourers to leave in a drive to apparently ‘clean up’ the city for the Commonwealth Games. The daily-wagers and labourers are being targeted
    in slums across the city by teams of Delhi Police, who are ‘deporting’ them, though no official written order exists. The affected workers allege policemen are rounding everyone without a valid Delhi address and identification proof and packing them off to railway stations. They are all being told not return before the end of the Games, on October 14.

    Like

    1. You are right.
      Its the poor who ultimately suffers because of such big ticket events like C’wealthgames , Olympics , WC Soccer….etc etc…..

      Same story everywhere….China , S.Africa , India….etc etc…..

      We gotta ban such games…….you agree??

      Like

  4. while they are at it why not remove lalu prasad yadav and other squatters from ministerial mansions and other government quarters. what will foreigners say when they find out. remove them at once!!!

    Like

  5. 165 million dalits are happy at least world leaders have seen the capability of hindus and their hindu led government in India.Child labour was the most important agenda for world communities who were financing hindu NGO to eradicate the child labour in India ,these NGO become nacked and most imortant things happened that Financial times,Wall street journal,Sunday times ,all news paper s of world had written about corruption and child labour,till now Hindu led government in India were hiding their crimes against the humanity under the banner of democracy but now they have seen their ugly face of hindu led government.Delhi chief miniter had stolen the 760 million rupees from dalit funds and her lier son told in front of medias that dalit funds was not used for CWG ,what a shame for Delhi CM and her son.we can say jai ho or shame ho for hindus and their hindu led government who had expend one lakh crores of rupees on CWG ,out of which 50% gone to hindus pockets.

    Like

  6. The unhappiness quotient of citizens of Delhi must be at an all-time high! I was visiting Delhi last week and was struck by the sheer unhappiness – discontent, anger, helplessness of ordinary people because of the CWG…
    while we measure the many acts of corruption and mismanagement that have dogged these games, when will people stop internalising this travesty as shame and show some constructive anger?

    Like

  7. Hay Guys ,have a look in Financial times,Wall street journal, and sunday time,what they had written about child labour in India and corruption in CWG.How long you people will hide your face under the banner of vibrant democracy.165 million dalits are happy that world leaders have seen true color of hindu led government in delhi and how delhi CM had stolen the 760 million rupees from dalit funds .we can say shame ho but other people will say jai ho.

    Like

  8. Out of one lakh crores, 50% gone to back pocket of Indian hindus because one cousin is helping other hindu cousin ,nothing else.money in circulation,we will say shame ho.

    Like

We look forward to your comments. Comments are subject to moderation as per our comments policy. They may take some time to appear.