We are publishing below an Open Letter written by concerned citizens to the Prime Minister opposing the dilution of MNREGA
Dear Prime Minister,
We are very disturbed by impending moves of this government to undermine the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) and the support it provides to crores of vulnerable rural families. We write this letter to seek your immediate assurance that these retrograde, anti-poor and anti-labour measures will be withdrawn, and that every attempt will be made by your government to implement the MGNREGA in its true spirit.
Based on recent public statements from Shri Nitin Gadkari, Union Minister of Rural Development, and other available information, we learn that the Central Government has initiated the following changes under MGNREGA:
- Restriction of NREGA to tribal/backward districts of the country through an amendment to the Act.
- Reduction of the minimum labour-material ratio from the current level of 60:40 to 51:49.
- Severely restricting the MGNREGA through a budget squeeze. There have been unprecedented communications by the Central Government to States capping MGNREGA expenditure for the rest of the financial year, undermining the fundamental principle of demand-driven employment.
These changes are inimical to the spirit of the Act and compromise its basic objectives. They will only benefit the contractor class and other middlemen, and severely undermine the employment generating potential of the MGNREGA. The changes are also being undertaken without any public consultation. The MGNREGA was passed unanimously by all parties and all members of Parliament. We fundamentally object to this critical social legislation being undermined through casual use of executive powers and even a parliamentary majority.
The illegal and unwarranted budget squeeze has led to widespread reports of employment rationing and acute delays in wage payments. Even as MGNREGA workers are struggling to be paid for work already done, the Central Government is sending the message that money is going to be further rationed.
The undersigned demand that your Government immediately revoke the above decisions and renounce any dilution of MGNREGA. We urge you to ensure that MGNREGA employment remains a legal right of every rural household across the country and that there is no dilution of any MGNREGA entitlements. The MGNREGA budget should be based on work demand, keeping with the spirit of the act, without any discretionary cuts.
Through this letter we also wish to convey our resolve to work together to protect the MGNREGA and defend the rights of MGNREGA workers.
With regards,
People’s Action for Employment Guarantee and other concerned citizens
(List of signatories attached)
| S. no | Name | Organisation |
| 1 | A.R.Vasavi | Senior Fellow, Nehru Memorial Museum and Library, New Delhi |
| 2 | Aban Raza | Artist |
| 3 | Abey George | |
| 4 | Abha Bhaiya | |
| 5 | Abhay Kumar | Grameena Coolie Karmikara Sangathane, Karnataka |
| 6 | Abhijit Sen | Former Member, Planning Commission |
| 7 | Achin Vanaik | Retired Professor of University of Delhi |
| 8 | Achyut Das | Agragamee, Odisha |
| 9 | Act Now for Harmony and Democracy (ANHAD) | |
| 10 | Afsar Jafri | |
| 11 | Aheli Chowdhury | JOSH |
| 12 | Alka | Independent Consultant |
| 13 | Amit Basole | Asst. Prof of Economics, University of Massachusetts, Boston, MA. |
| 14 | Amit Bhaduri | |
| 15 | Amit Sengupta | Journalist |
| 16 | Amitabh Behar | Executive Director, NFI |
| 17 | Amman Madan | Azim Premji University |
| 18 | Anand Chakravarti | Retd Prof of Sociology. Delhi University |
| 19 | Anand Patwardhan | Filmmaker |
| 20 | Anant Bhatnagar | PUCL |
| 21 | Angela Rangad | Thma U Rangli-Juki (TUR), Meghalaya |
| 22 | Anil Sadgopal | |
| 23 | Anita Dighe | |
| 24 | Ankita Aggarwal | |
| 25 | Annie Koshie | |
| 26 | Annie Raja | General Secretary, National Federation of Indian Women (NFIW) |
| 27 | Anuradha Kapur | |
| 28 | Anusha Rizvi | Filmmaker |
| 29 | Aruna Burte | |
| 30 | Aruna Rodrigues | Sunray Harvesters |
| 31 | Aruna Roy | Member, Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan (MKSS) |
| 32 | Arundhati Dhuru | NAPM |
| 33 | Ashim Jain | |
| 34 | Ashish Kothari | Kalpavriksh |
| 35 | Ashish Ranjan | Asst. Professor, BIT Mesra |
| 36 | Ashok Gladston Xavier | Head, Department of Social WorkLoyola College-Chennai |
| 37 | Ashwini Kulkarni | |
| 38 | Badri Raina | |
| 39 | Battini Srinivas Rao | Convener, Peoples’ Alliance for Democracy and Secularism |
| 40 | Bela Bhatia | Economist |
| 41 | Bezwada Wilson | Safai Karamchari Andolan (SKA) |
| 42 | Bhaskar Prabhu | Mahiti Adhikar Manch, Maharashtra RTI Council |
| 43 | Bhupender Singh Rawat | NAPM |
| 44 | Bhupendra Yadav | Azim Premji University |
| 45 | Bijayalaxmi Nanda | |
| 46 | Bimla Chandrasekar | |
| 47 | Binalakshmi Nepram | Founder Manipur Women Gun Survivors Network/Secretary General Control Arms Foundation |
| 48 | Binayak Sen | PUCL |
| 49 | Biplab Halim | General Sec. FIAN, West Bengal |
| 50 | Biswajit Mohanty | |
| 51 | Boobli George Verghese | Senior Journalist |
| 52 | Brinda Singh | |
| 53 | Bunker Roy | Barefoot College, Tilonia |
| 54 | Chandan Gowda | Azim Premji Foundation |
| 55 | Chetanram Godara | Secretary, Urmul Jyoti Sansthan Nokha, Bikaner |
| 56 | Chhaya Datar | |
| 57 | Cynthia Stephen | President, TEDS Trust andDalit Women’s Network for Solidairy (DAWNS) |
| 58 | D.L. Tripathi | PUCL |
| 59 | David Amalanadane | |
| 60 | Deep Joshi | PRADAAN |
| 61 | Deepak Nayyar | Economist |
| 62 | Devaki Jain | Economist |
| 63 | Dilip Simeon | |
| 64 | Dinesh Gaur | |
| 65 | Dinesh Mohan | Professor, IIT, Delhi |
| 66 | Dolly Daftary | Academic, USA |
| 67 | Dr GPI Singh | |
| 68 | Dr Sanjeev Mahajan | |
| 69 | Dr Shaikh Ghulam Rasool | Chairman J&K RTI Movement |
| 70 | Dr V Rukmini Rao | Executive Director, Gramya Resource Centre for Women |
| 71 | Dr. Indrajit Roy | ESRC Fellow, Department of International Development, University of Oxford |
| 72 | Dr. Kanchan Mathur | Professor, IDS, Jaipur |
| 73 | Dr. Syeda Hameed | Former Member, Planning Comission |
| 74 | Dunu Roy | Hazards Centre, Delhi |
| 75 | Dyuti Ailawadi | |
| 76 | EAS Sarma | IAS (retd.) |
| 77 | Elina Horo | Adivasi Women’s Network, Jharkhand |
| 78 | Faisal Khan | Khudai Khidmatgar, NAPM |
| 79 | Farah Naqvi | Former Member, National Advisory Council |
| 80 | Flavia Agnes | |
| 81 | Francois Buisson | |
| 82 | Gabriele Dietrich | NAPM |
| 83 | Gargi Chakravartty | NFIW |
| 84 | Gautam Bhan | |
| 85 | Gautam Navlakha | Human Rights Activist |
| 86 | Girish Nikam | Journalist |
| 87 | Govind | Jagruk Nagrik Munch Nokha, Bikaner |
| 88 | Guliben Nayak | Devgadh Mahila Sangathan |
| 89 | Gurjeet Kaur | ActionAid |
| 90 | Gurjeet Singh | |
| 91 | Gurwant Singh | NAPM, Punjab |
| 92 | Harbans Mukhia | Historian |
| 93 | Harjinder Singh | |
| 94 | Harsh Mander | Special Commissioner to the Supreme Court |
| 95 | Hemaram | Jagruk Nagrik Munch Nokha, Bikaner |
| 96 | Henri Tiphagne | Honorary National Working Secretary, Human Rights Defenders’ Alert, India (HRDA) |
| 97 | Himanshu Thakkar | |
| 98 | ICAN | |
| 99 | Ilina Sen | |
| 100 | Imrana Qadeer | Professor, CSD |
| 101 | Indian Christian Women’s Movement | |
| 102 | Indira Hirway | |
| 103 | Indira Jaising | Former Additional Solicitor General |
| 104 | Ira Pande | |
| 105 | Irfan Engineer | |
| 106 | Jan Sangram Parishath (JSP) | |
| 107 | Jasmeen Patheja | |
| 108 | Jayanti Banerjee | |
| 109 | Jayati Ghosh | Professor, Jawahar Lal Nehru University |
| 110 | Jean Dreze | Visiting Professor, Ranchi University |
| 111 | John Dayal | Member, NIC. Secy. Gen. All india christian Council |
| 112 | Justice Chandru Krishnaswamy (Retd.) | |
| 113 | Justice Rajindar Sachar | |
| 114 | Jyothi Krishnan | |
| 115 | K Raju | IAS (retd.) |
| 116 | K.A.Matthews | State Committee Member, CCJAT |
| 117 | Kamal Chenoy | |
| 118 | Kamayani Bali Mahabal | Jan Swasthya Abhiyan, Mumbai |
| 119 | Kamayani Swami | Member, Jan Jagran Shakti Sangathan (JJSS) |
| 120 | Kamla Bhasin | SANGAT |
| 121 | Karuna M. | Social Audit Unit, Tamil Nadu |
| 122 | Kathyayini Chamaraj | Executive Trustee, CIVIC Bangalore |
| 123 | Kavita Srivastava | PUCL, Rajasthan |
| 124 | Kiran Bhatty | Senior Fellow, Center for Policy Research |
| 125 | Kiran Shaheen | Writer and activist |
| 126 | Koninika Ray | NFIW |
| 127 | Krishnakant | NAPM |
| 128 | LABIA collective (Stree Sangam) | |
| 129 | Lakshmi Krishnamurty | |
| 130 | Lalit Mathur | IAS (retd.) |
| 131 | Leela Samson | Artist |
| 132 |
|
|
| 133 |
|
Educationist |
| 134 | M.G.Devasahayam | |
| 135 | Madhu Bhaduri | Former Diplomat |
| 136 | Mahesh Bhatt | Filmmaker |
| 137 | Mahmood Farooqi | Historian |
| 138 | Maj Gen S.G.Vombatkere | (Retd), Mysore |
| 139 | Mallika Sarabhai | Artist |
| 140 | Manasi Pingle | Filmmaker, Bangalore |
| 141 | Manish Jain | Ambedkar University, Delhi |
| 142 | Manisha Sethy | |
| 143 | Manoj Mitta | Journalist |
| 144 | Manoj Thokchom | Administrator, Human Rights Initiative (HRI), Manipur |
| 145 | Mary E. John | |
| 146 | Mathew Cherian | HelpAge India |
| 147 | Medha Patkar | Narmada Bachao Andolan and NAPM |
| 148 | Media Action and Research Group | |
| 149 | Mohan | Jagruk Nagrik Munch Nokha, Bikaner |
| 150 | Monisha Behal | North East Network |
| 151 | Moti Charu | MAMONI (Sankalp) |
| 152 | Mukul Kesavan | Professor, Jamia Milia Islamia |
| 153 | Mukul Mangalik | Associate Professor in History, Ramjas College, University of Delhi |
| 154 | N.Chithra | Advisor, Tamil Nadu Federation of Women Presidents of Panchayat Government |
| 155 | Nandini Sundar | Sociologist |
| 156 | Nasim Ansari | Director, Tarun Chetna-Pratapgarh (U.P.) |
| 157 | National Committee for Protection of Natural Resources (NCPNR) | |
| 158 | Navin Narayan | Action Aid |
| 159 | Nayanjyoti | Krantikari Naujawan Sabha |
| 160 | Neeta Hardikar | Anandi |
| 161 | Nikhil Dey | Member, MKSS |
| 162 | Nimisha | OBR, India |
| 163 | Niti Saxena | (CAWL) |
| 164 | O.P. Ray | |
| 165 | Osama Manzar | Digital Empowerment Forum (DEF) |
| 166 | Ossie Fernandes | Director, Human Rights Advocacy and Research Foundation |
| 167 | P. Sainath | Author and Senior Journalist |
| 168 | Padma Velaskar | Tata Institute of Social Sciences |
| 169 | Padma Vibhushan Prof. M S Swaminathan | Agricultural Scientist and Geneticist |
| 170 | Pankaj Bhushan | G M Free Bihar Movement |
| 171 | Pankaj Butalia | |
| 172 | Persis Ginwalla | |
| 173 | Ponnuthai | Women Farmers Association, Tamil Nadu |
| 174 | Poornima Chikarmane | |
| 175 | Prabhat Patnaik | Economist |
| 176 | Pradeep Esteves | Director, Context India, Bangalore |
| 177 | Praful Bidwai | Senior Journalist |
| 178 | Prahlad Shekhawat | Alternative Development and Research Center Jaipur |
| 179 | Prashant Bhushan | Senior Counsel, Supreme Court |
| 180 | Prashanto Sen | Advocate |
| 181 | Prof. Ayesha Kidwai | Centre for Linguistics, Jawaharlal Nehru University |
| 182 | Prof. V. S. Vyas | Professor Emeritus, Institute of Development Studies, Jaipur |
| 183 | Purnima | Women’s right activist, New Delhi |
| 184 |
|
|
| 185 | Rakesh Reddy Dubbudu | Convenor – United Forum for RTI Campaign, Telangana |
| 186 | Ram Rahman | |
| 187 | Ram Tahiliani | |
| 188 | Ramaswamy R Iyer | Former IAS officer |
| 189 | Ranesh Ray | |
| 190 | Ranjana Ray | Dr. AV Baliga Memorial Trust |
| 191 | Ranjit Paswan | JJSS, Bihar |
| 192 | Ravi Chopra | |
| 193 | Ravi Hemadri | Development and Justice Initiative |
| 194 | Ravi Nitesh | Mission Bhartiyam |
| 195 | Rawatram | Jagruk Nagrik Munch Nokha, Bikaner |
| 196 | Reetika Khera | Associate Professor, Indian Institute of Technology Delhi |
| 197 | Right to water Campaign | |
| 198 | Rohini Hensman | Writer, Researcher, Mumbai |
| 199 | Rohit Kumar | Lawyer, National Campaign for the People’s Right to Information (NCPRI) |
| 200 | Rukhiben Pagi | Panam Mahila Sangathan |
| 201 | S. Anandalakshmy | President, Bala Mandir Research Foundation, Chennai |
| 202 | S.Vijayashankar | Advocate |
| 203 | Sagar Rabari | |
| 204 | Saheli Women’s Resource Centre | |
| 205 | Sahiyar (Stree Sangathan), Vadodra | |
| 206 | Saikat Ghosh | Professor, IIT Delhi |
| 207 | Sakthi Vadivel | State Committee Member, Coastal Action Network |
| 208 | Sangeetha Sivakumar | Artist |
| 209 | Sanjay Sharma | |
| 210 | Satish Deshpande | Professor, Delhi University |
| 211 | Seema Kulkarni | (CAWL) |
| 212 | Seema Mustafa | Director, Center for Policy Analysis |
| 213 | Sejal Dand | (CAWL) |
| 214 | Shafiq R. Khan | Empower People |
| 215 | Sharada Gopal and the GKS | Grameena Kulikarmikaara Sangathana |
| 216 | Sheba Chhachhi | |
| 217 | Sheelu Francis | Women’s Collective, Chennai |
| 218 | Sheetal Sharma | North East Network, Assam |
| 219 | Shekhar Singh | Academic |
| 220 | Shomie Das | |
| 221 | Shyamolie Singh | |
| 222 | Siddhartha Basu | Author |
| 223 | Smita Gupta | Indian School of Women’s Studies and Development, Delhi |
| 224 | Soma KP | Collective for Advancement of Knowledge and Action on Women’s Livelihood Rights (CAWL) |
| 225 | Sowmya Kidambi | Director, Society for Social Audit Accountability and Transparency, Andhra Pradesh and Telangana |
| 226 | SR Hiremath, | Founder President, JSP & NCPNR |
| 227 | Sr. Geeta Carol | |
| 228 | Stalin K | Video Volunteers |
| 229 | Stree Mukti Sanghatana | |
| 230 | Subhash Gatade | Writer and member of New Socialist Initiative |
| 231 | Suchi Pande | Independent Researcher |
| 232 | Sudha Mahalingam | |
| 233 | Suhas Borker | Convener, Working Group on Alternative Strategies |
| 234 | Suhas Kolhekar | NAPM Convenor, Maharashtra |
| 235 | Sujata Gothoskar | |
| 236 | Sukumar Muralidharan | Senior Journalist |
| 237 | Sumi Krishna | |
| 238 | Sumit Chakravartty | Editor, Mainstream Weekly |
| 239 | Summa Josson | Filmmaker |
| 240 | Suraj, Pune, Maharastra | OBR, India |
| 241 | Suravaram Sudhakar Reddy | Communist Party of India |
| 242 | Suroor Mander | |
| 243 | Swami Agnivesh | |
| 244 | Ramakrishnan | |
| 245 | Tamil Nadu Women’s Forum | |
| 246 | Tamilarasi | State Committee Member, TamilNadu Housing Rights Campaign |
| 247 | Tapan Bose | Filmmaker |
| 248 | Tarun Bhartiya | Thma U Rangli-Juki (TUR), Meghalaya |
| 249 | Tarunabh Khaitan | Associate Professor, Oxford University |
| 250 | Teesta Setalvad | Citizens for Justice and Peace (CJP) |
| 251 | TM Krishna | Musician |
| 252 | Trilochan Sastry | IIM, Bangalore |
| 253 | Tushar Gandhi | Mahatma Gandhi Foundation |
| 254 | Uma Chakravarti | Formerly of Miranda House, University of Delhi |
| 255 | Usha Rai | |
| 256 | Utsa Patnaik | Economist |
| 257 | V.Indira | Co-convenor, TamilNadu Child Rights Protection Network |
| 258 | Venkatesh Nayak | Programme Coordinator, Access to Information Programme, Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative |
| 259 | Vidya Subrahmaniam | Senior Journalist |
| 260 | Vijay Bharatiya | |
| 261 | Vikram Vyas | Physics Department, St. Stephen’s College, Delhi |
| 262 | Vinod Mehta | Author and Senior Journalist |
| 263 | Vivan Sundaram | Artist |
| 264 | Wajahat Habibullah | Former Chairman, National Commission for Minorities |
| 265 | Women for Water Democracy | |
| 266 | Women’s Coalition For Change | |
| 267 | Yamini Aiyar | Senior Fellow, CPR |
| 268 | Yogendra Yadav | CSDS |
| 269 | Yug Mohit Chaudhry | Senior Advocate |
| 270 | Zoya Hasan | Political Scientist, JNU |
I support this appeal.
Manish Thakur, IIM Calcutta
LikeLike
If possible add my name: Subhash Mendhapurkar SUTRA Himachal Pradesh
LikeLike
How can one sign this petition?
LikeLike
I support this letter wholeheartedly
LikeLike
I also extending my solidarity to the letter in its real spirit. I have witnessed the changes in the livelihood of thousands of rural community especially central India those who used to migrate for a better livelihood option before the enactment and implementation of NREGA (S) in the state. I had two or three opportunity to participate in some seminar where opinions of social activists academics and general public including direct beneficiaries were also took part. There was a welcome sign in the progress of the implementation of the scheme in the rural areas throgh the participation of community based organisations with focus on the multiple objectives of the scheme like creation of community assets, equal wages for women beneficiaries as well as inclusion of differently abled, and various marginalised sections. NREGS need to be strengthened in the coming days without diluting its goals and objectives.
LikeLike
All the indian peoples are with this letter becoz poor peoples are living around the country not in limited areas so plz dn’t restrict mgnrega
LikeLike