Condemn the Attack on Kancha Ilaiah for asking, ‘Is God a democrat?’

[We at Kafila condemn the repeated  attacks on scholar activist Professor Kancha Ilaiah by the Hindu Right and  the recent case registered against him by the Hyderabad police. According to a Times of India report, Ilaiah had on May 14 delivered a lecture in Vijayawada in a programme entitled `Nationalism and Divergent Views’ organised by CITU where he reportedly criticised Hindu gods and scriptures, according to the police. Following this an advocate filed a private petition in the court of the XI Metropolitan Magistrate court, Ranga Reddy , requesting to register an FIR under relevant sections of IPC. The court directed cops to register a case under sections 295 A (deliberate and malicious acts, intended to outrage religious feelings of any class by insulting its religion or religious beliefs),153 A (promoting enmity between different groups on grounds of religion) and 298 (uttering, words, etc. with deliberate intent to wound the religious feelings of any person) of IPC.”

Earlier, last year the  VHP had initiated a campaign against him which was followed by the filing of a case against him by the Hyderabad police. That was in relation to an article Kancha Ilaiah had written, asking ‘Is God a Democrat?’ The story by Ajaz Ashraf from linked below refers to last year’s case but due to an inadvertent mix-up, was initially extracted by us as the one in the eye of the current controversy. The error is seriously regretted and we thank one of our readers for pointing this out. The Times of India report linked to above gives refers to the speech that is currently in the eye of the storm.

Professor Ilaiah has now himself described the current attacks on him in this piece in, where he signs his article as Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd, recalling his caste name (translated into English, in order to mark his distance from the brahmans).

The attacks on  Professor Ilaiah are totally unacceptable. We have all read and long admired his writings. Many of us have hugely benefited and learnt a lot from them. The time has come for us to collectively put our heads together and fight this menace of Hindutva, which after hurting every living being’s dignity and sentiments, has now begun claim to be the perpetual and universal victim. Dalits today cannot speak of the indignities and oppression that they have suffered at the hands of the Hindus – even that has become a matter of ‘hurt sentiments’. The response has to be worked out politically and intellectually so that the law is not repeatedly turned into a surrogate of Hindutva politics.]

The Hyderabad police have registered a case against renowned social scientist Kancha Ilaiah, after Vishwa Hindu Parishad activists complained that an opinion piece he wrote in the Telugu newspaper Andhra Jyothi had hurt their religious sentiments.

They filed their complaint at Hyderabad’s Sultan Bazar Station was filed on May 9, the day Ilaiah’s article titled Devudu Prajasamya Vada Kada? (Is God a democrat?) was published.

VHP activists Pagudakula Balaswamy, Thirupathi Naik and two others accused Ilaiah of comparing Hinduism with Islam and Christianity, insulting Hindu Gods by comparing them to mortals, mocking their worship, and for attempting to trigger clashes between upper and lower classes (by which they presumably meant castes).

On the basis of their complaint, Inspector P. Shiva Shankar Rao wrote a letter to the Senior Assistant Public Prosecutor, who advised the police to register a case under Section 153 (A) and Section 295 (A), which empower the authorities to act against people who commit deliberate and malicious acts aiming at outraging religious sentiment and spreading enmity between groups.

Case under investigation

The public prosecutor’s legal opinion led to a case being filed on May 15 against Ilaiah, the management of the Andhra Jyothi newspaper, its editor and publisher. The case is currently under investigation, at the completion of which a decision will be taken to whether to chargesheet them.

A police officer at the station told Scroll that Ilaiah is in the habit of articulating provocative views in his articles, which can and do hurt the sentiments of people. “Why does he have to make comments against practices which are dear to people?” the officer said, declining to give his name.

Read the full article here

8 thoughts on “Condemn the Attack on Kancha Ilaiah for asking, ‘Is God a democrat?’”

  1. The Scroll article by Ajaz Ashraf is date-lined May 31, 2015 What is the status of the case as of now?

    1. Thanks for pointing that out. The link is to an earlier case against him last year. There is however a fresh case against him now regarding a speech he made on nationalism on 14 May.Here are links to two other story in the Times of India and The News Minute:

      Will make the necessary corrections in the post.

  2. Anyone including prof. Illiah has the fundemental right to ask questions. Anyone has a right to comment on any scripture of any religion. The article of illiah is an ‘ eye opener’ to the decadent brahminical thought. His writings may be criticised with supportive arguement but attacking him is heinous crime. He should be given adequate protection.
    Many before him have criticised god. Tanganayakamma has written a work ‘ Ramayana vishaVriksham’ (The poisonous tree of Ramayana) and she too was threatened.
    The attack itself indicates that the BJP/VHP / RSS and other goons have no answer to illiah’ s writings. Their intolerance reflects that they cannot defend god. This is the first step of their failure and success of illiah and atheism . Also, this is the time to propagate budhism and the sermons of Gautama Budha taken from real life experiences.

  3. This has all the potential to become a textbook instance of Streisand effect. Can someone please do the needful and post a translation of the article (anonymously, if required)?

  4. Ashamed of this behaviour. No true followers of the Hindu tradition would do this. Especially when our tradition provides for a multitude of ways to realise oneself as there are saints.

  5. The attack on Prof. Illiah is deeply regrettable, howsoever provocative his thoughts or writings are.

    I ,however, disagree vehemently with Prof. Illiah as regards his understanding of so called Hindu religion .

    Hindu religion , as I have been saying it is uniquely different from Christianity and Islam , two religions which Professor has compared it with. There is no all controlling God as are in Christianity and Islam. There is no book which prescribes what to do and what not to do for people in society . One may not worship or follow anything and yet be a Hindu without any religious sanction, without any branding of being apostate, without any dictat of punishment by any authority. What more could be more humanistic than this .

    Yes, I agree , in order to force a pan-Hindu identity, an attempt has been made to organize Hindu calling people on the lines of a religion called Hindu, inspired by Christianity . But that is not the true spirit of Indian religions.

    Prof Illiah’s views about ecclesiastical religions like Christianity and Islam being more democratic reeks of some deliberate attempt to prove a point against so called Hindu religion, which is sad.

    If he has stuck to problems being faced by Indian society due religious practices , it would have appeared alright. There are severe problems being faced by practitioners of other religions in India, like radicalization , education, oppression of women, etc. His views seem to be a kind of deliberate articulation based selective facts to buttress a theory designed for a kind of audience .

    Though I condemn violence with Prof. Illiah very strongly, I find myself saddened by his deliberately provocative views.

    1. Very true! Very honest views based on actual facts. I think it is quite courageous to express honest opinion which may not have any readymade audience. My admirations !

Leave a Reply to sandeepanb2005 Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s