Letter to Arvind Kejriwal: Women against Sexual Violence and State Repression

Women against Sexual Violence and State Repression condemns the racial profiling, sexual violence and vigilantism by AAP against Ugandan women.

Women Against Sexual Violence and State Repression (WSS) is a network of women’s rights, Dalit rights, human rights and civil liberties organizations and individuals across India. It is a non-funded grassroots effort by women to stem the violence being perpetrated upon our bodies and on our societies by the State’s forces, by non-state actors and by the inability of our government to resolve conflict in a meaningful, sustainable and effective manner.

Women against Sexual Violence and State Repression strongly condemns the illegal raid conducted by the AAP cabinet law minister, Somnath Bharti and his mob of supporters, on the premises of the Ugandan women on 17th January 2014 residing in Khidki village, New Delhi.

One media report states that four women who were kept in a taxi for 3 hours were accused of conducting ‘drug rackets’ and ‘sex rackets’; and were terrorized by your cabinet minister and his mob. The women, who were eventually helped by the police, have registered their statements. Two of them have stated that they were physically assaulted by the mob and were also subjected to intense racist abuse – “black people break laws.”

Media reports also indicate that for the purpose of collecting their urine samples, one of them was forced to urinate in public. To add to this abuse and trauma, they were also subjected to not only body search but humiliating invasive physical searches of their private parts. This search is a part of the routine custodial violence that women are often subjected to.

As a group in solidarity with women who face violence, we are appalled to learn of this incident which reeks of gross violation of not only the constitutional law but of human rights as well.

In its party manifesto, AAP had professed to follow the rules of the law, vowed to create a safer society for women, and punish the sexual offenders. But, in the light of this incident, we are deeply disappointed to note that your party has demeaned the credibility of its own manifesto by going against it and engaging in such disturbing acts.

Your law minister has not only wilfully and fearlessly broken the law but it is shocking to see that instead of taking a decisive stern action against Somnath Bharti, you and your cabinet colleague, Manish Sisodia, defend his racial profiling and violent vigilantism under the pretext of preventing ‘rape tendencies’. We find it inexplicable that when in another shameful incident, a Danish woman was gang raped, the AAP leadership immediately and rightfully recognized it as violence against women but it failed to take cognizance of the same offence when it was inflicted through the agency of its own cabinet minister.

To add insult to injury, in less than 24 hours, in a further appalling act Somnath Bharti returned to the very spot on Thursday and asked the residents to draw up a list of houses where ‘such people’ lived and assured them that he would personally check on each one of them. This act is leading to a power structure similar to the regressive Khap Panchayat, where residents are being given the dangerously partial authority of deciding on the basis of their personal and cultural prejudices on who might be a suspect or not. In a country where we have witnessed serious assaults on civil rights on the basis of religion, gender, caste and class, such authority is a potential threat to the civil liberties. If we do not collectively condemn it and proactively combat it, sooner or later we would all be prey to the same.

Legal protection from police barging into people’s homes and arresting them without search/ arrest warrants is a safeguard that has been fought for and established in democratic societies by the constitution. Violating the law was a very shameful act on the part of the Minister who ironically has been given the same responsibility of protecting and upholding the very law he willfully disobeyed. And to defend his acts, makes your stand not just shameful, but it is hazardous to the social well being of any citizen of this state. No one should be allowed such violation under any circumstances. Further, to put the foreigners who have chosen this country to work in or study in is shows India in very poor light. By doing this, you forsaken many Indians based abroad for education or work.

We stand in solidarity with the women who were subjected to the violence that night and strongly feel that such racist, sexist and moral zealots and vigilantes have no constructive role to play in a party that claims to be a common people’s party, aims to prevent violence against women and seeks to promote diversity and tolerance.

We would like to iterate that:

* There are guidelines by the Supreme Court restated time and again which insist that women cannot be questioned by the police at night, that notice of any search etc has to be given in advance so that women can be prepared for the same.

* That the law clearly lays down the process to be followed by the police which includes the absolute necessity of a search warrant and at least a complaint, if not an FIR to back the same.

* That an assumption cannot be made simply because a couple of women of colour are living together, that they indulge in solicitation for the purpose of prostitution or otherwise.

In the light of the above, WSS demands that:

1. By violating the same law that he pledged to uphold, Somnath Bharti, has proved unfit to be a law Minister, and should be removed from his position.

2. A judicial probe should be ordered by the lieutenant Governor to identify those who instigated and perpetrated the violence against these Ugandan women and also other African nationals in Khidki village.

3. All found guilty of such violence be punished as per the law, including the law minister.

4. The Ugandan women are compensated

5. The police who came to the help and protect those women from the mob violence, followed the rules of the law and refused to raid without a search warrant must not be suspended. Instead they should be made answerable for not filing the FIR of the affected women.

6.  AAP must render an apology to the women and others Africans in the country. They should stop spreading racist propaganda such as ‘all Africans are drug peddlers’’ who engage in ‘sex rackets’, and should actively discourage others engaging in the same.

7. AAP should promote tolerance and encourage diversity in Delhi and other parts of the country.

Kalpana Mehta, Rinchin and Geeta Charusivam, National Conveners, WSS

(On behalf of Women Against Sexual Violence and State Repression)

11 thoughts on “Letter to Arvind Kejriwal: Women against Sexual Violence and State Repression”

  1. SO what do we have as proof here-oh the pious print media reports. The same people are fighting on the streets for Sexual Violence against women but we would not stand for that. All that we wish to do is to issue statements sitting inside our offices. Please from next time onwards do give video links for the charges that you people have been continously levelling against them. You can also go in that area and ask from people of that constituency, if any one of them has seen the minister forcing the women to urinate in public. Please do give us some evidence.

    Like

  2. I quite agree with this letter. However, i am not sure about the media reports that remain the basis for this condemnation. Media is out there to turn AAP members into scapegoat. And, there is nothing wrong in it too. The problem starts when we conveniently pick and choose mainstream media reports. The resident welfare association office bearer of the area where this particular incident took place was on NDTV yesterday. His version did not match with what Barkha Dutt wanted to hear from him. He was not allowed to speak again because his statement complicated the media reports.

    Like

  3. I have always wondered how one would force somebody to urinate in public? I personally suffer from stagefright even when asked to do it on command in a Doctor’s office. The media was present when Bharti said and did his apparent acts. Where is the video showing this? Why has it not been broadcast?

    Like

  4. Well written Nivedita. When the mob decides `morality’ we get what we got. It is inexcusable that a person like Yogendra and Kamal were trying to defend the AAP on NDTV show last evening. On the other side, the AAP is trying to tell us is: how and what Aam Adami of this country `thinks’ and `feels’ about `women of other colour’ which I am ready to contest. Men getting organised against `rape’ is an old phenomena, but fighting against racial prejudices is another ball game and I am sure AAP shall not be able to understand the difference between the two.

    Like

    1. A clarification on the authorship of this letter – it is by WSS – as clearly mentioned in the title and at the beginning. As a Kafila member I have only posted it. I happen to agree with most of what the letter says, but it is not MY open letter to Kejriwal.

      Like

  5. Let me ask yet another question to all those who condemn all this. The police is not in control of Delhi ministers and yet the minister and others can make a woman urinate forcefully, while the “Honest police ” was standing there???
    Aren’t these the same “trusted police” people who weren’t even ready to raid a house in the name of minister???

    Like

    1. This all controversy which is being demonstrated in fornt of rail Bhawan is the best strategy of Congress to prevent the news on Modi go air. After two days session of Modi and BJP, news channels were airing only Modi versions . AAP has camouflaged the Modi effect now. Congress is not going to solve the issue very soon. They will drag it for days together to prevent the media to bring Modi to TV screens. Media is also gertting befooled by these tricks of congress.

      Otherwise also, let the BJP, Modi jump to any extent and raise their voice against Congress and AAP, there is a hard fact and bitter truth that “MODI WILL NEVER BE ABLE BECOME INDIA’S PRIME MINISTER., LET WHAT MAY COME.” And after genral election of 2014, some of the BJP people will definitely go mad when they see their party not getting the throne of rule of india.

      By supporting AAP, congress herself has committed suicide and murdered the BJP. Next Govt will be in coalition amongst AAP, BSP, SP, RJD, JD, CPI(M). BJP walas will grow older than older but will not get on to seat of PM of India.

      Best strategy for BJP walas in todays scenario is not to foment poison against congress and AAP, rahter they should keep quiet, watch and smile quietly. The more they foment in these days, more they are going in ditch. In fact after the rise of Kejriwal party to Delhi CM Post, they are feeling hapless and becoming day by day “Hopeless”

      BJP should have supported AAP in Delhi agitation agaisnt Delhi Police, that could have helped them a lot. But Alas ! I think brain has fallen down somewhere on the way.

      Like

  6. Neither Som Nath Bharati nor Kejriwal has taken any wrong action. Those who sya them wrong, I feel pity on them. Are they fighting and agitating for any personal cause ? NO ! They are not !. They are on the roads in midnight for the cause of AAM Admi. And in the struggle of AAM admi, AAM ADMI has to face some inconvenience. to get some thing long lasting, one will have to some price and that price is some inconvenience. Kejriwal is right and all his member leaders minister are on right path. Shinde is favouring police peoples who are generally assumed to be corrupt. .

    Like

    1. This is hilarious. The supposed eye witness simply says, I am a Gandhian, we could never do such things. The Ugandan woman was not made to give a urine sample in the open, I know this. On asked but is the woman lying then, this “eye-witness” says – because she was caught red-handed, she is lying.
      How was she caught “red-handed”? The “eye-witness” does not explain. She was certainly caught by the mob, but the urine samples on testing revealed no signs of drug usage.
      So nothing has in fact been proved against the Ugandan women or woman, but you have a self-righteous “eye witness” claiming that because she is a “Gandhian” we should believe her.
      Did Avinash even watch this clip, or did he simply gloatingly post this on the basis of the thoroughly misleading headline?
      Please keep this kind of mindless reproduction of links for your FB page.

      Like

Leave a reply to Jpallipad Cancel reply