Guest post by NOOPUR TIWARI
I woke up in Paris last weekend to the news of the Delhi protests. I felt relieved. People are not just watching or suffering quietly anymore, I thought to myself. I wanted to be there too, out in the streets of Delhi. For all those times I had to suffer sexual harassment in Delhi, I want to be part of this churning for change now.
My Parisian friends asked me what was going on. And I told them about the new “national outrage” and the stories that had been stoking the anger. That’s when I realised I needed to make a list. What was informing my idea of what’s going on? These stories making it to the headlines, do they have something in common?
-cases with voyeuristic descriptions of how women are stripped or paraded naked;
-rapes that involving a celebrity;
We need to be careful here. These stories “sell” better than other reports of violence against women. They fire up people easily and the most recent has even triggered a ‘movement’. Awareness is a good thing half-baked awareness is not. While we are in the mood to fight for change let’s also be aware of the risks we’re running.
By highlighting only these sensational stories, we are making only these rapes seem “real” and making other, more common forms of rape, such as acquaintance rape or marital rape, seem “unreal” or not serious enough to require strict action. Let’s not forget the crimes against women that are being committed every day but not making it to headlines. The suffering of those women also deserves outrage.The Indian media has made a huge effort to break a common rape myth: that women “invite” sexual assault or harassment and that their life is “ruined” if they are raped. This has made a difference to the way in which we talk about victims and survivors. We slam the Khap leaders for saying rapes happen because women fail to do enough to shield themselves from uncontrollable male desire. We make Sheila Dikshit eat her words for saying a woman who is out very late at night is being too adventurous. We give room to “survivors” on television rather than feel sorry for “wrecked victims”. That’s perfect. But we still haven’t realised that the way we talk about the perpetrators of sexual crimes remains seriously flawed.
Rapists are being called “crazed animals” who cannot control their vile sexual impulses and anger. We’ve already heard reports in the media about how Ram Singh was a “volatile man” and his friends call him “mental”. One report says, “Singh is a cold and remorseless”. In fact, we are constantly trying to classify the perpetrator an outsider, someone on the fringes, a monster. Even the Prime Minister in his address spoke of “monstrous crimes”. But rather than say “they are beasts” we should really be saying “they are men”. That brings the responsibility of the crime squarely back on us, for tolerating societal norms that have led to a fierce culture of violence against women.
“When we are forced to confront the reality of a real live rapist, the discourses of both bestiality (“these people are animals!”) and madness are both summoned up, establishing a trend of constantly pushing the rapist to the bounds of society, in order not to have to recognise the one in our workplace, our home, our bed.”
(“Rape Crisis. Women Against Violence Against Women”. Capetown Trust.)
Delhi Police Commissioner, Neeraj Sharma, said on TV that the recent Delhi gang rape case will be treated as “rarest of rare”. The media let him get away too easily! By calling this case “rare” the police is trying to say “no one is responsible”. Speaking of this crime as an aberration, leads to the idea, that no one could have done anything about it.
“By presenting stories of violence against women as separated isolated events, the news media reinforces the idea that the violence was an isolated pathology of deviance. Maintaining this mirage of individual pathology, the news media denies the social roots of violence against women and absolves the larger society of any obligation to end it.”
(“Monsters, playboys, virgins and whores: Rape myths in the news media’s coverage of violence” Shanon O’Hara, 2011.)
There is another dangerous trend in these reports. The stories being played up are often about victims from the middle class and rapists from poorer sections. In the recent Delhi gang rape case, the victim was a medical student and the prime accused a bus driver. In the Bombay Purkayastha case, the woman was a lawyer and the criminal a security guard. In both cases, these men wanted to “teach a lesson” to these women, both women were “better off” than them. In the Rueben and Keenan case, the press talked of “national rage” and here’s how the accused were described in a paper: “One of them is a labourer, another is a barber while the rest are unemployed, police said.”
A fear psychosis is building up about these “other” men from weaker social classes who are turning against educated, free women. The idea taking root is that these social classes are full of sexual deviants and more and more depraved men are attacking innocent, free thinking, middle class women. In reality, let’s not forget, that these are not the only rapes that are being committed, they are simply the only ones being reported in greater numbers.
With each rape case that gets wide coverage, the anger and the hysteria multiplies. “Hang the rapists in public” is the common refrain one hears on the social media. One particularly violent set of images, where a mob lynches a rapist in Lebanon, was doing the rounds on Facebook. Someone wondered why we weren’t doing the same to rapists in India. And sure enough, “national rage” led to the lynching of as many as five men for sexual harassment in Jharkhand. One journalist was shot dead by the police in a protest in Imphal. The media really needs to tread very carefully now. There’s a thin line between media activism and whipping up hysteria. The protesters have to be cautious too. Saying no to violence cannot be done with more violence.
There is still a great deal that is not said and not reported in the media about violence against women. We need to start making room for the stories that have been ignored or forgotten as we go along. Our fervour to get justice for women is well-meaning and our media is trying to make sense of it all. But our anger and emotions can also be manipulated. Let’s not forget that there will be sane voices but also misled ones. There will be TRP wars, lumpen elements and populist appropriation that will keep adding distortions to the larger picture. As individuals, whether we work for the media or consume it, we will have to constantly scrutinise what we are saying, why we are saying it and what it is leading to.
(Noopur Tiwari is a journalist in Paris.)
More from Kafila:
- Bakht Arif, from Pakistan, sings Zinda Lash for Patronizing Indian Politicians (No, Don’t Listen to Honey Singh)
- How Delhi police assaulted my daughter on 25 December: Usha Saxena
- An ‘I Witness’ Account of Delhi Police and RAF Violence at India Gate on 23 December: Sangeeta Das
- Armed Forces Special Powers Act provides impunity for rape: Warisha Farasat
- Stop Shielding Criminals in the Army and Security Forces in Assam: Bondita and Anjuman
- Play Haze Kay not Honey Singh: Music from Kashmir against Rape for Delhi
- Rape is allowed because most people don’t know what it is: Anonymous
- Sexual Violence and Sexuality Education – The Missing Link: Ketaki Chowkhani
- Misogyny, Politics and Zombiedom: From Sonia Gandhi to Botsa Satyanarayana
- How the God of Death Changed His Mind: Images from the Protest Against Rape at Jantar Mantar
- This is to clarify a small misunderstanding: Anusha Rizvi
- How not to think about violence against women: Noopur Tiwari
- Statement by women’s and progressive groups and individuals condemning sexual violence and opposing death penalty
7 thoughts on “How not to think about violence against women: Noopur Tiwari”
Reminds me of a book on Jefferey Dahmer, called “Men and Monsters: The Construction of a Serial Killer”.
A well written piece, and about time!
hey noopur, thanks for voicing something which has been playing within me for days… media has a grt responsibility and we from within this fraternity can give a shape to this change — a shape that allows women to be as they want to be not as others want them to be…
this can happen by responsible reporting — like u said there’s a thin line bet reporting a changing (media activism)
and whipping a mass hysteria and the journalistic fraternity has enough grey cells within itself to decipher the difference!
Reblogged this on Wanderlust.
Supremacy of men,in a sexually oppressed society of India that rules women, devalues, demeans and disrespects them, , causes acts of rape, violence, murder, torture by men.
In a repressed society , coming out of a caste system, where men still rule, where people can lie and be bought off for money, laws need to be harsher to create needed reform to promote the equality of men and women and children. Rape is unacceptable to anyone, no matter their race, gender, sexual preference, and age, A man does not enjoy being raped, a woman does not enjoy being raped, a child does not enjoy being raped, an employee does not enjoy being raped. Rape is violence against the body, soul, mind and spirit,one never forgets. People carry their scars for life.
What these 5 men and I teenager did was senseless and horrific. Indian society has taught them well because laws and respect are not in place to stop them.They beat , tortured, held kidnapped,assaulted, sexually assaulted, repeatedly gang raped, humiliated, striped her nude and threw her body in the street, tried to run over her with a bus, and when she begged for her life by biting 3 of her rapists, they “decided to teach her a lesson” and rammed a metal tube up her insides damaging her (many?)organs and threw her into the dirt. Now add murders to the list, A waste of a lovely just 23 year old who had a life, a family, wifehood and children and a career ahead of her, and to make her parents proud, She will never marry, never have children, never see the sun rise again, never graduate, never help her elderly parents later in life. You 6 men “psychologically murdered “her parents as well. Sadly, this is not just India, rape is an international phenomena, aided by internet pornography, inequality of the genders in societies, and where cultures have an inherent disrespect for human beings and have put in place proper laws to create respect and dignity. In the beginning, there needs to be stricter and harsher laws and penalties to stop rape, then once society has changed the laws can be reviewed and loosened. Public awareness and education also aids change , a change in the policing system with female officers and a rape team, trained specialists, and lawyers who can’t be bought off.
Please, I ask people around the world, to keep pressuring the Indian government, the United nations, The Hague, Presidents around the World, the red Cross , and International agencies, to intervene, politically advocate, and maintain pressure on this government to stop rape, deal with rapists harshly, and put programs in place for women who have experienced violence, and raise the standards for women.
DO NOT LET THIS YOUNG 23 YEAR OLDS LIFE GO IN VAIN, SHE GAVE HER LIFE HEROICALLY FOR CHANGE. DO NOT REST IN PEACE, UNTIL WE GET IT FOR HER
A CALL FOR “THE NEW INDIA!!!”
ASK FOR”THE NEWQ INDIA”