Which COURT of Justice for Vinay Sirohi?

Yesterday, in a corner of Delhi-NCR known as Keshopur, a 22-year old sewage worker breathed his last, a final tortured breath inhaled inside a part of the vast network of sewage pipelines that map the city in their own cartography of waste. The pipeline was owned by the Delhi Jal Board, so its function was not simply to transport sewage, but to transform it into potable water through a portion of the pipeline that resembles a septic tank – a portion known as the ‘digester’.

The portion of the pipeline containing Vinay Sirohi’s body. Courtesy Indian Express online edition.

That Vinay Sirohi, 22-year old contract worker with the Delhi Jal Board, who got married last year and had taken up part-time employment to help him get through college, lost his life in a part of the sewage pipeline called the ‘digester’ imparts something so grotesquely apposite to this tragedy that one almost doesn’t want to think about it. One often doesn’t, of course. One has the option of of flipping the page of the newspaper, of resting one’s eyes on more life-affirming images – English Premier League, Bollywood, Modi-Cameron Cameron-araderie…even Kejriwal’s homely navy-blue sweater and baggy trousers are a pleasant distraction. Anything that tells us that life as it was meant to be – humans wearing a clean sweater and trousers with a sofa to sit on after their stomachs and minds are fed and sated – is better than the thought of a body inside a pipe under the city. When I tried to save the image that you see above, the caption read djb_body_759. I don’t want to think about what that caption means. Does it mean the 759th body found inside the DJB’s sewage network? Does it mean the 759th body to have been recovered by the police this year, 2015? Does it mean the 759th body to have died in sewage pipelines across the country, or ever?

When I looked for the story online, I found just one comment below it – one Mr Jain from the United States writes,

Delhi Jal Board is under the control of Arvind Kejriwal, He is in the habit of blaming everybody,without seeing the malfunctioning of his departments.It is glaring that that there was neither any safety precaution arrangement, nor any supervisor to oversee such a dangerous work at a big sewage treatment plant. It appears that no close circuit cameras have been provided to oversee the functioning of the treatment plant, otherwise that would have helped in many ways. a young life has been lost, my heart goes with the family of the victim of negligence.

I was happy to see that on a medium that seems to attract a thousand commentators on big-ticket national issues, a person was moved enough to comment on the loss of a sewage worker’s life. The credit must got to the Indian Express, which instead of burying the story in proportion to the burying of the body inside the pipeline, or the burying of the problem of worker deaths (murders is more like it as I have maintained earlier) inside the opaque figures of national GDP, placed it on the ‘skyline’ above the newspaper flag on the front page, and followed it up with two reports including one of Sirohi’s mother and young wife on page 3. The credit must also go to this year’s Indian entry to the Oscars – the quietly brilliant Court, which refused to let us look away for the entire 116 minutes of its running length. Delivering a series of slow punches to our increasingly steel-lined stomachs, it reminded us why we are still a deeply screwed-up, grossly class-divided nation where even a well-meaning, liberal-minded judge has the option of looking away, of convincing himself of the rightness of his writ as he slumps into his well-deserved nap on his hard-earned family holiday…while a wrongly convicted man swelters in jail through the summer, and perhaps for posterity.

The problem however, with Mr. Jain’s comment is this. Before he expresses solidarity with the grieving family, before he acknowledges the negligence that took young Vinay’s life, he begins by blaming Kejriwal and scoring a brownie point for the opposition. Mr Jain’s excoriation of the Kejriwal government is absolutely correct and deserved. This is an event which must invite the highest action from the state government, on a scale that ensures it doesn’t happen again, and far more than the pathetic compensation of rupees 1.5 lakhs that has been announced. It must hold the DJB accountable, which is already showing signs of passing the buck to the contractor (According to DJB officials, Sirohi was a contractual employee at the STP and had been hired by VA TECH WABAG Limited, a private company, as a valve operator for the plant), or worse, back to Sirohi and to his own carelessness.

The Delhi Police in the meanwhile, unpublished but acclaimed authors of potboiler fiction, holy seers who know the result of the match before the first ball is bowled, have begun to say that since call records were deleted from Sirohi’s phone, they suspect foul play. Incredible! The police is willing to undertake responsibility for a criminal investigation assuming a personal enmity, motive and intent to murder instead of assuming the obvious – that another young life has been brutally cut down in its prime because nobody bloody cares about safety equipment for workers. That while the DJB piously maintains in its press statement after the death that nobody should go inside a sewage manhole or pipe without safety equipment, they are free to routinely neglect safety procedures by outsourcing the entire job to a contractor. That at the end of the day, if a life is lost, the Delhi Police can always be marshalled to ring up its favourite conspiracy theory about the secret enemies cultivated by Sirohi. That like “Court” shows, it is not the Kejriwal government or the Modi government or the Sheila Dixit government that is responsible, but a society in which life is cheap for the working classes. Consider the lack of safety equipment amongst municipal garbage workers for instance – a phenomenon that democratically spreads across every municipality in the country, and in the case of Mumbai is documented brilliantly in a documentary that the makers of Court watched during prep for their film – Jai Bhim Comrade. That sewage pipeline and manhole deaths are a nearly daily occurrence in this country, and over 95 percent of those entering these chambers of death with their noxious gases are Dalit and/or extremely poor, from families that don’t have the imagination, leave alone resources to sue the state. That these are murders, plain and simple, made possible by the structure of society. Like a ritual sacrifice demanded by the gods of the Indian development model.

I am culpable. You are culpable. Mr. Jain, you too are culpable. Let nobody insult the memory of Vinay Sirohi.

7 thoughts on “Which COURT of Justice for Vinay Sirohi?”

  1. My heart goes out for the worker who sacrificed his life for the ‘hygiene’ of humanity.
    The unemployed youth of this country are treated pathetically to say the least. Especially, the poor are made to work on the most dangerous jobs to make a living. Jobs like drainage cleaning, mining, road construction digging of tunnels, etc., are fraught with danger and there are no safety guidelines. Even if some guidelines exist, workers are ignorant and he supervising officers do not care to read, let alone explain the workers. Sometimes these workers risk their lives, going deep into the earth and live on days for together suffering asphyxiation and slow death. It is a shame that the country (especially those in power, bigbbusiness men , the contractors, etc.) which boasts of ‘the most humane’ in the world, just does not care for these ‘part-time contract’ workers. Parties at the Centre and State keep busy with internal bickerings and external accusations rather than looking at the workers and providing them with accessories so as to do jobs like this more efficiently and free of risk.
    Thanks for allocation of ‘due space’ for the lives of these great humans.

  2. Sewage work should be made compulsory for every citizen. Each day, a different family’s turn to go under. Am certain within 5 days we’ll have a better system sorted for dealing with sewage. For this, what is going on, the sheer apathy, is just plain ridiculous.

    1. Perfectly agree with you. I have long believed that in a deeply stratified society like India’s an important step is to ensure that all of us are involved in cleaning and sewage work. If we have to clean toilets, roads, gutters, we will learn much about our own selfishness, inequality, poverty, indifference and policy and state spending on worker safety. Why are some of us too important to clean after ourselves – and I don’t mean living rooms and toilets in our homes – but streets and cities? Secondly look at the paltry wages all these workers are paid. Thirdly, yes outsourcing is a way of washing hands off of these responsibilities to some of our most marginalised peoples. The chain becomes so complex and convoluted it is easy and possible for everyone to deny responsibility.

  3. Its so tragic n unfathomable to even imagine that we are so callous to the worth of a human life…just another news item we read, feel bad on and move on but why did it happen at all..why vinay had to die? Why such pain for his family?mainly because nobody cares to replace this life threatening low grade job with a better unmanned sytem…hope its the last such thing, and its not an accident.It is a result of sytematic denial.

    1. Truly moving, Sunalini. Yes, no words can cover up the guilt that each of us bears in his death. And to think that technology is now available and no human being need to go through this … and we simply do not fight to get that in place …

  4. There is a department called “labour department” which is responsible for implementing Factories Act and Delhi Factories Rules under Kejriwal Govt. The department is also responsible for investigating all workplace mishaps. This department is responsible for neglect due to its failure to oversee absence of workplace safety.

We look forward to your comments. Comments are subject to moderation as per our comments policy. They may take some time to appear.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s