Tag Archives: Delhi rapes

Political-Emotional Architecture of Bharosa – From Kitchen to Street: Rashid Ali

Guest post by RASHID ALI

The word ‘Bharosa’ feels far too ordinary to demand serious analytical scrutiny. Yet, North Indian social life is entirely entangled in its everyday usage. It anchors everything from marketplace haggling to deep emotional intimacies, structuring how people negotiate dependence, heavy obligations, faith and expectation. Recently, protesting students in Delhi threw a sharp new light on the word ‘Bharosa’ with a viral slogan: ‘Ek chai do samosa/Mard zat ka kya Bharosa’ (One cup tea, two samosas/ can men ever be trusted?). Had Roland Barthes been raised in a North Indian milieu, ‘Bharosa’ would likely have emerged as a foundational concept in his semiotic arsenal in the ‘Image, Music, Text.’

While linguists trace the word to its Persian roots, ‘Bharosa’ has actually migrated through the messy, overlapping realities of both Sanskrit and Persianate cosmopolises. In doing so, it has taken on a vibrant social life that can’t be contained by a single religion, language, caste or gender. Today, competing ideological camps use ‘Bharosa’ to define inclusivity and exclusivity. Left-wing discourse, for example, ties ‘Bharosa’ directly to the fragile contracts between democracy, revolutionary hope and the bourgeois state. Conversely, Hindutva politics leverages the vocabulary of trust to forge shared goals within its own defined enclave, while explicitly painting specific identities as outsiders. The nation-state itself operates on this exact axis, repetitively bordering on the citizens it trusts and it doesn’t. Continue reading Political-Emotional Architecture of Bharosa – From Kitchen to Street: Rashid Ali →

How Would You Like your Death Penalty Steak, Rare, Well Done, or Medium Rare?: Arguments Against the Death Penalty

The anger that I felt when a young woman was brutally raped and killed by a group of men on the night of December 16 last year is not something that will ever go away. It marked not just me, but millions of people in Delhi, and elsewhere. That anger has no closure. Nor do I seek the convenience of such a closure. I do not seek the convenience of closure for the rape and murder of dalit women in Haryana, or of women in Kunan-Poshpora and elsewhere in Jammu & Kashmir or in Manipur who were raped and killed by the soldiers of the Indian army and who are still unpunished. I would like such men to be punished, but I will never demand the penalty of death for them. Not because I have any affection for rapists, but because I have a greater regard and respect for human life, which I do not think that we should allow the state to take away, in cold pre-meditation, whatever the circumstances.

Continue reading How Would You Like your Death Penalty Steak, Rare, Well Done, or Medium Rare?: Arguments Against the Death Penalty →